10 Unpopular Opinions About Jean Grey From The Comic Books According To Reddit

10 Unpopular Opinions About Jean Grey From The Comic Books, According To Reddit

Despite being an Omega-level mutant, many comic book fans aren’t all that impressed by Jean Grey, and some even actively dislike her.

You Are Reading :[thien_display_title]

Jean Grey is one of the founding members of the X-Men who has appeared in some of the franchise’s most famous storylines. In arguably the X-Men’s most well-known storyline The Dark Phoenix Saga, she was the story’s central tragic figure who experienced the old adage “absolute power corrupts absolutely.” She has since become a legendary figure among comic fans, who admire her resiliency and strength when faced with impossible odds.

Yet despite her prominence in comics, television shows, and feature films, the telekinetic mutant is disliked by a small but vocal subset of comic fandom. Many perceive her as too weak, which is surprising considering she’s an Omega-level mutant and the most emblematic host of the Phoenix Force. Indeed, many Reddit users use the discussion site to share their unpopular opinions about the character, which range from mildly negative to outright hateful.

10 Jean Grey Is Underrated

By her very nature, Jean Grey is a divisive character. Some appreciate her innate leadership, while others think her power and superhero expertise is exaggerated. But in Redditor MaximumSpidercide’s opinion, Jean is actually underrated.

The user explains how Jean “is a good and perhaps misunderstood character.” They go on to elaborate on how she’s a character full of contradictions and dualities and how those elements come into play in her most significant relationships: Scott, Professor X, and Logan. It’s a compelling argument, and the user clearly has an enormous appreciation for Jean. Yet with Jean headlining the current X-men title, and as the central figure in the last main X-Men movie, it’s hard to accept she’s underrated when she has no much media exposure.

9 Jean Grey Deserves A Superhero Name

Superhero names are a perfect and easy way for audiences to know these characters. Symbolic codenames reveal a great deal about the character’s powers while also offering a brief glimpse of their personalities. For example, fellow X-Man Jubilee’s codename both describes her mutant abilities (she can generate fireworks) and her personality (colorful, loud, and vibrant).

Redditor ExplanationsNeeded thinks that Jean Grey is long overdue for a proper alias. They dislike the character’s original moniker, Marvel Girl, considering it uninspired and too rooted in the 1960s. Furthermore, they think that Phoenix is incorrect because Jean and the Force are now two separate entities. Fortunately, they have a suggestion to fix the issue: “Psion is such a great name for her.” While the quality of that name may be debatable, the need for a new codename for Jean is not.

8 The All-New X-Men Version of Jean Is Tiresome

All-New X-Men debuted in 2012, centering on one of the best team X-Men rosters in Marvel Comics: Cyclops, Angel, Ice-Man, Beast, and Jean. In the series, the team travels from the past into the present to confront their future counterparts. Jean serves as the de facto lead character, and some fans took issue with that.

Reddit user BlueAlchemy disliked Jean’s characterization, calling her “annoying” and “very bratty with her powers” who took the spotlight away from other characters. While it’s true that Jean was yet again the focus of attention, All-New X-Men broke new ground by making her a leader for the first time. The series showed that even as a teenager, Jean was a strong character that didn’t need the Phoenix Force to become powerful.

7 Jean Grey Is A Hard Character To Write

Jean has always been a tragic character brimming with contradictions. As Reddit user Zmikey explains, “(Jean) is either seen as a maternal woman who is always right in her ways; a strong woman on the verge of mental instability; or the most powerful being in the galaxy who is also evil incarnate.”

Writers often struggle with writing complex characters. Indeed, Jean’s death was one of the most heartbreaking in X-Men, and writers keep coming back to it, creating a perpetual sense of doom around her. The Redditor calls that “lazy writing” because it denies her any growth as a character. While this is true for some X-men writers, most use Jean’s death as an endless source of inspiration that generates new storylines like the “Phoenix Five” concept in Avengers vs. X-Men.

6 Grant Morrison Didn’t Understand Jean Grey

In the comic book world, Grant Morrison is a highly respected author. The writer and playwright employs a nonlinear and humanistic approach to their stories, and he’s behind some of the most acclaimed comic books of the last 25 years like All-Star Superman and JLA.

However, some fans take issue with Morrison’s approach to the X-Men. In a Reddit discussion thread about the character, Redditor sw04ca states that “Morrison took all the fire out of” Jean. Other commentators agreed with them, with one even claiming that Morrison “really seemed to dislike” Jean. Not a lot of people share this opinion, as Morrison is widely viewed as one of the few writers who understood Jean and gave her one of her best storylines in “E is for Extinction.”

5 Jean Grey Makes No Sense In The Ultimate Comics

Ultimate X-Men received universal commercial success and a mixed-to-positive critical reception. The series abandoned all the supernatural and mystical elements of the franchise in favor of a more grounded approach, but not all fans understood it.

Redditor davonian explains in their thread that they “don’t understand the character of Jean Grey in (the Ultimate Comics line).” The commentators try to give their reasonings for Jean’s mental state, but the consensus seems to be that she became a zealot after watching her friends die during the Ultimatum event. The Ultimate version of Jean is often misunderstood and while she underwent a few transformations during her existence, she was no more or less confusing than her regular Eath-616 counterpart.

4 Jean Grey Manipulates The Men Around Her

In a thread that simultaneously flatters and attacks the characters, Redditor depotboy claims that Jean Grey constantly manipulates those around her. “Jean Grey is subconsciously (or possibly consciously) sending telepathic signals that make most people around her like and love her.”

It’s an intriguing proposal, and most commentators agree that would explain why everyone seems to love her, no matter what she does. But it’s too out of character for someone like Jean, who’s always been portrayed with high moral integrity.

3 Jean Grey Vs. Wanda Maximoff

In all of Marvel canon, perhaps no two characters are pitted against each other more than the Scarlet Witch and Jean Grey/ Phoenix Force. With the release of WandaVision, the Witch’s popularity is at an all-time high, and some fans even argue that MCU Wanda already has a better Dark Phoenix storyline than Jean ever had.

Redditor player13010 can’t understand how anyone would say Jean would win against the Witch. “Couldn’t Wanda speak Jean out of existence?” Commentators on the thread explain that, by that logic, Jean could “turn off Wanda’s ability to speak.” In the end, Redditor Upallnite922 explained it best, saying, “it depends on specifics… or which version of them you’re discussing.”

2 The Dark Phoenix Saga Is Overrated

Fans and critics consider The Dark Phoenix Saga as the best and most emblematic X-Men storyline ever. Widely considered a classic, the saga is a landmark for the X-Men comics and marks a distinctive before and after in the team’s history.

Not everyone is a fan of the storyline, though. Reddit user brizzenden doesn’t understand the appeal, saying they “can’t figure out why it’s considered a classic.” The user goes on to describe the story as “brief, not epic” and “emotionally shallow.” To each their own, but on this matter, brizzenden is one of the few who shares this unpopular view.

1 The Dark Phoenix Saga Shouldn’t Have A Third Live-Action

Four comic book storylines have become synonymous with the X-Men: God Loves, Man Kills, Days of Future Past, Age of Apocalypse, and The Dark Phoenix Saga. Fox already adapted all these into their movies, but they failed miserably with Dark Phoenix. In fact, they did it twice, and the storyline now seems unadaptable.

“Should the MCU even bother with The Dark Phoenix Saga?” That’s the question Redditor MasterCaster2000 asks, and most commentators seem to agree with the OP, at least on that thread. Yet just because there have been two subpar adaptations doesn’t mean the MCU should forgo a third one. Under Kevin Feige’s expert watch, the storyline could finally be accurately portrayed on the big screen.

Link Source : https://screenrant.com/marvel-jean-grey-comics-unpopular-opinions-reddit/

• 5 Best & 5 Worst High School Movies According To Rotten Tomatoes

• 10 Best Quotes From The Magic Mike Movies

• 10 Coolest Star Wars Statues From Sideshow Collectibles Ranked

• 90 Day Fiancé David Murpheys GF Lana Shares Major Relationship Update

• All Zelda Ocarina Of Time Switch & N64 Differences

• 10 Best Time Travel KDramas Ranked (According To IMDb)

• 90 Day Fiancé Evelin Calls Out Coreys Girlfriend Jenny On Her Lies