Gilmore Girls 10 Unpopular Opinions About Max According To Reddit

Gilmore Girls: 10 Unpopular Opinions About Max, According To Reddit

While most Gilmore Girls fans ship Lorelai and Luke, some love Max, and they’re sharing their unpopular opinions about this relationship on Reddit.

You Are Reading :[thien_display_title]

For countless Gilmore Girls fans, Luke Danes is Lorelai Gilmore’s one true love. Luke’s grumpy attitude is the perfect match for Lorelai’s fast-talking, caffeinated personality, and they belong together, no matter how many problems they have. Many viewers agree with Lorelai’s decision in season 2 to cancel her wedding to Max Medina, as Lorelai doesn’t feel that things are right between them.

While Max is kind, intelligent, and interested in committing to Lorelai, many Gilmore Girls viewers feel that he’s problematic and that he can be too intense. Several fans have shared their unpopular opinions about Max on Reddit.

10 Max Is A Better Partner For Lorelai Than Luke

Luke and Lorelai’s romantic Gilmore Girls scenes are always memorable to fans, and when comparing Max and Luke, most viewers would say that the diner owner is Lorelai’s best match. It’s enjoyable seeing Luke and Lorelai’s bond develop and they have a lot of hilarious moments as well.

For Reddit user WildGeese1969, they enjoy watching Max and Lorelai’s love story and think that Max has better qualities than Luke. The fan wrote, “He’s more emotionally intelligent than Luke.” This might not be the most popular opinion, but it’s an interesting one.

9 Max And Lorelai Don’t Have Timing On Their Side

Max and Lorelai’s relationship definitely crashes and burns. They date for a brief period of time before getting engaged and don’t talk much about what the future will look like before Lorelai decides that she can’t get married. Reddit user loveandmakeup has a different perspective, saying, “there was nothing wrong with Max but timing.”

This is a new take since most fans think that Max and Lorelai have a lot of problems, from not communicating enough to getting engaged too quickly. Some viewers also think that their relationship is a problem right away since Max is Rory’s English teacher at Chilton.

8 It’s Confusing That Lorelai Cancels Her Wedding

Fans always enjoy coming back to the Gilmore Girls episode “The Road Trip To Harvard.” It all starts with Lorelai realizing that marrying Max would be a giant mistake.

But while most fans agree with Lorelai, one Redditor doesn’t think that Lorelai ending her engagement to Max makes sense. The fan explained, “I felt that her refusal was quite out of the blue, the problems Lorelai had with Max felt rushed in the last episode.” Not everyone agrees with this as the general feeling is that Lorelai and Max aren’t serious enough about each other to continue to the next level.

7 Max Would Be A Great Stepfather

One Redditor thinks Max would be an amazing stepparent for Rory, writing, “All of his qualities were what would’ve been best for a potential father-figure for Rory, but were at odds with what Lorelai needed or wanted.”

Even though Max is an intelligent and passionate teacher, he’s not the most likable character, with many fans believing that he’s too intense and that he should back away from his relationship with Lorelai. Not everyone feels that he could parent Rory well, but this fan feels he has some good qualities.

6 Max Isn’t Prepared For Marriage, Either

When Gilmore Girls fans look back on Lorelai calling the wedding off, the focus is often on Lorelai’s fear of commitment and all the ways that she’s not prepared to get married. But what if Max isn’t actually ready to take their relationship to the next level?

Reddit user Mlcoulthard wrote, “they weren’t at all ready to get married. They hadn’t met each other’s families or had any sort of life together as partners before getting engaged.” This is a great point as it’s true that Lorelai and Max seem to race through their engagement and before fans know it, their wedding is approaching.

5 Max Doesn’t Deserve Lorelai’s Poor Treatment

While she’s strong and smart and compelling, Lorelai can be immature, and it’s easy to move past the fact that she leaves Max right before they’re supposed to get married. The show focuses on the fun that Lorelai and Rory have on their road trip, staying at a quirky inn and joking around. But could Lorelai have handled this situation in a more appropriate way?

One Redditor shared their unpopular opinion on the subject and wrote, “I am one of the minority who thinks Lorelai treated him horribly” because she ran away. The fan wrote, “No one deserves that.”

4 Lorelai And Max Have A Lot In Common

Many Gilmore Girls fans prefer Luke and Lorelai to Max and Lorelai because they don’t think that the latter couple has anything in common. For Reddit user applecherrypear, “they got along they had similar humor and interests” so they were a good couple, but “Lorelei refused to become vulnerable.”

It’s easy to focus on the pain that Lorelai and Max are in when they don’t get married, but they do have some good times earlier on in their relationship. It’s interesting and true that Lorelai doesn’t share enough with him.

3 Max’s Proposal Isn’t Great

When it comes to swoonworthy proposals, many TV fans like when Max sends 1000 yellow daises to Lorelai’s inn, as it feels dreamy and special. For Reddit user Lyxoes, it’s not a very interesting proposal at all. The fan wrote, “Not original in the least. He wasn’t even present. He bought tons of flowers to Lorelais workplace.”

While this fan doesn’t like this proposal and thinks that Max could have asked Lorelai to marry him in person, others think that it’s the perfect way for Max to share his feelings. It’s also true that this is an iconic scene that fans will always think about.

2 Max Loves Lorelai’s Sense Of Humor More Than Christopher And Luke

When looking back on Lorelai’s Gilmore Girls love interests, many feel that Christopher really gets her as a person and that Luke appreciates her silly side, too. But what if Max is the person who truly understands Lorelai?

For Reddit user Cheesieblaster, Max understands Lorelai’s jokes better than Chris and Luke, and that’s why they’re perfect together. The fan explained, “I think he was the best match for Lorelai. He was the only one of her boyfriends who understood and appreciated her jokes, her witticisms and could keep the banter going.”

1 Max Excels As A Teacher

Most fans think that Max ignores necessary boundaries by dating the mother of one of his students, and they also don’t like that he talks to Rory about Lorelai at school.

One fan has the unpopular opinion that Max is an amazing teacher. Reddit user susono wrote that Max is caring and compassionate and when it comes to his students, “He cares enough to make sure he’s understanding them correctly.”

Link Source : https://screenrant.com/gilmore-girls-reddit-max-unpopular-opinions/

• How To Hide The MacBook Pros Ugly Notch Once And For All

• How Much The Xbox Series X Could Cost

• How Strong Ironheart Could Be In Black Panther 2 (Could She Beat Namor)

• GTA Trilogy Nintendo Switch Versions First Screenshots Revealed

• Justice League Reveals Dark Truth About Superman & Black Adams Powers

• Gilmore Girls 10 Scenes Fans Love To Watch Over & Over

• Harry Potter 10 Things the Movies Leave Out About the Noble House of Black